Selling Away

FINRA Bars Broker Joseph Pappalardo Over Allegations of Sales of Coast-2-Coast Properties Securities to Customers

October 24, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) barred broker Joseph Pappalardo (Pappalardo) concerning allegations that between August 2008, and August 2012, Pappalardo, while associated with Financial Network Investment Corporation (n/k/a Cetera Advisor Network LLC), made fraudulent and misleading misrepresentations to a customer in the sale of private securities, converted customer funds for his personal use, engaged in private securities transactions (a/k/a “selling away”), failed to disclose several outside business activities, and failed to amend his U4.

Pappalardo joined Financial Network Investment Corporation in 2008 and was required to complete a several questionnaires including disclosures of outside business activities. In 2008, FINRA alleged that Pappalardo disclosed on the questionnaire that he had previously been involved with a real estate company he formed in 2003 called Coast-2-Coast Properties (C2C) that was in the business of buying, renovating, and selling houses but that the company was no longer in business. FINRA alleged that Pappalardo’s statement was false. In fact, FINRA found that Pappalardo was involved in several outside business activities that he failed to disclose to Cetera including ongoing involvement in C2C and its marketing arm Prosperity Financial Estate Planning and Insurance Services (Prosperity Financial).

Thereafter, FINRA found that Pappalardo solicited customers to invest in these businesses. In one instance, FINRA found that Pappalardo solicited the sale of a $100,000 investment in Prosperity Financial which Pappalardo converted for his personal use. In total, FINRA found that Pappalardo solicited C2C to at least 6 customers and purported to offer investors 12% interest returns on profits generated by the business. FINRA found that the investors did not actually own any portion of the real estate properties held by C2C but instead were to receive interest returns on profits from Pappalardo and the business. FINRA found that by engaging in the C2C private securities Pappalardo violated the FINRA rules.

Broker Edward Wendol Barred by FINRA Over Failure to Respond to Outside Business Activity Inquiries

October 16, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) barred broker Edward Wendol (Wendol) concerning allegations that during the course of FINRA’s investigation into whether Wendol was involved in undisclosed outside business and private securities transactions, also known as “selling away”, Wendol failed to respond to FINRA’s requests. On May 29, 2014, FINRA requested that Wendol provide documents and information. On June 16, 2014, Wendol informed FINRA that he would not provide the requested documents and information or appear and provide testimony. As a result, Wendol was barred from the securities industry.

Wendol first became registered with FINRA in 1993 with South Richmond Securities, Inc. From October 1993, through October 2009, Wendol was registered with seven different FINRA member firms. On December 5, 2011, Wendol registered with Sterling Enterprises Group, Inc. (Sterling). Thereafter, from September 2013, through July 2014, Wendol was associated with WTS Proprietary Trading Group LLC.

The allegations against Wendol are consistent with a “selling away” securities violation. In such a case, the broker sells private securities away from the firm because the investment is not approved by the broker’s affiliated firm. Under the FINRA rules, a brokerage firm owes a duty to properly monitor and supervise its employees. In fact, each brokerage firm is required to establish and maintain a system to supervise the activities of each registered representative that is reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the securities laws. Selling away often occurs when supervisory lapse conditions exist. Supervisory lapses include either the failure to put in place a reasonable supervisory system or a failure to implement their supervisory requirements. Many times there obvious “red flags” of misconduct that are overlooked or not properly followed up on.

Dennis Karasik Barred by FINRA Over Diversified Energy Group Sales

October 10, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) permanently barred broker Dennis Karasik (Karasik) concerning allegations that from December 2010, to March 2012, Karasik participated in private securities transactions, otherwise known as “selling away” without providing prior written notice to the two firms with which he was associated. Specifically, FINRA alleged that Karasik participated in the sale of bonds issued by Diversified Energy Group, Inc. (DEG), an energy company, and that the company paid him finder’s fees from on the sales made.

Karasik was employed by a number of brokerage firms from 1986 through February 2013. During the times relevant to FINRA’s allegations Karasik was registered with Multi-Financial Securities Corp. (Multi-Financial) until December 2011, and with H. Beck, Inc. (H. Beck) until February 2013. Karasik maintained an office in Parkton, Maryland. Karasik was terminated by H. Beck for the conduct alleged by FINRA. According to Karasik’s BrokerCheck, he has had six customer complaints filed against him and also has two tax liens. Karasik was also a partner of Carrio, Karasik, & Associates (CKA).

DEG is a Florida energy company that develops oil and gas reserves in the United States. It has raised funds through private placement offerings of corporate bonds to accredited investors. FINRA alleged that between January 2010, and March 2012, Karasik and his partner in CKA participated in the sale of more than $3.2 million of DEG bonds to at least 25 investors. According to FINRA, Karasik was compensated for his role in these sales through the payment of a finder’s fee.

Gana LLP is Investigating Benjamin F. Edwards in connection with the Firm’s Supervision of Aon Miller

October 3, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

Gana Weinstein LLP, a nationally recognized securities arbitration boutique, is investigating Benjamin F. Edwards & Company, Inc. (“BFE”) in connection with the firm’s supervision of its former registered representative Aon D. Miller.

From November 2011 through September 2012, it is alleged that Aon D. Miller, participated in five different securities transactions with three different entities in which four of his customers invested a total of approximately $1,550,000. According to FINRA, who is also investigating Mr. Miller, he failed to inform Benjamin F. Edwards of his outside business activities as he was required to do. Aon Miller allegedly participated in three separate entities outside of his employment with Benjamin F. Edwards. The three entities at issue are: i) CDP, a real estate development company; KBI, a specialty chemical company, and iii) CTL, a company that refinanced senior secured debt.

According to FINRA, the above mentioned transactions resulted in a violation of FINRA Rule 2010 and and selling away, a violation of FINRA Rule 3040. FINRA Rule 2010 states in relevant part that “A member, in the conduct of its business, shall observe high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.” FINRA Rule 3040 states in relevant part that “prior to participating in any private securities transaction, an associated person shall provide written notice to the member with which he is associated describing in detail the proposed transaction and the person’s proposed role therein…”

FINRA Suspends former Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Broker Travis Shannon for Failing to Divulge Information

October 2, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

On August 25, 2014, FINRA suspended Travis S. Shannon, of Santa Barbara, California, formerly of Morgan Stanley Smith Barney. According to FINRA, from July 2010 through June 2013, Mr. Shannon engaged in two outside business activities without first providing written notice to Morgan Stanley, in violation of FINRA Rule 2010, 3030, and 3270. FINRA Rule 2010 states that “A member, in the conduct of its business, shall observe high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.” All members are bound to maintain high standards and according to FINRA Mr. Shannon fell short of that standard.

FINRA Rule 3030 states that “No person associated…shall be employed by, or accept compensation from, any other person as a result of any business activity…outside the scope of his relationship with his employer firm, unless he has provided prompt written notice to the member.” This activity is known as selling away. Mr. Shannon was employed as a financial advisor with Morgan Stanley from September 2008 through July 2013 when he was allowed to voluntarily resign from the firm due to FINRA’s regulatory action. According to FINRA, Mr. Shannon participated in private sales of $1,885,000 worth of securities, including securities issued by his outside business activities. Mr. Shannon also failed to timely update his U4 registration form to timely report two bankruptcy filings.

In June 2010, Mr. Shannon first began to participate in the private sales of securities issued by TC, a company that bought and sold used computer network equipment. Mr. Shannon referred eight customers to this company including four Morgan Stanley customers. Those eight purchases totaled $775,000 in investments with commissions of $77,500 to Mr. Shannon. In July 2010, Mr. Shannon co-founded AAI or Aerobat Aviation, Inc., a start-up company that was to design and produce unmanned aerial vehicles. In 2012 and 2013 Mr. Shannon participated in the private sale of $500,000 worth of Aerobat Aviation Inc. stock.

Broker Ismail Elmas Terminated Over Outside Business Activities

September 22, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

According to broker Ismail Elmas’ (Elmas) Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) BrokerCheck records the representative was recently discharged from CUSO Financial Services, LP (CUSO Financial) concerning allegations that the broker “converted client funds for personal use as well as participated in an unauthorized outside business activity involving investments without the firm approval…” Previously Elmas was associated with CUNA Brokerage Services, Inc.

Shortly thereafter, a customer filed a complaint against Elmas alleging that the broker took the client’s variable annuity contract, surrendered it, and sent the proceeds to a third-party – which the client says was unauthorized activity. In addition, since Elmas was terminated from CUSO Financial authorities have been unable to locate the broker. In articles, officials say that Elmas, 49, has been missing since July 29^th and have warned that Elmas may be armed and should not be approached. According to reports Elmas was last seen leaving his home in his gray 2008 Toyota Prius.

The allegations against Elmas are consistent with a “selling away” securities violation. Selling away occurs when a financial advisor solicits investments in companies or promissory notes that were not approved by the broker’s affiliated firm. Under the FINRA rules, a brokerage firm owes a duty to properly monitor and supervise its employees. In order to properly supervise their brokers each firm is required to establish and maintain a system to supervise the activities of each registered representative to achieve compliance with the securities laws. Selling away often occurs in environments where the brokerage firms either fails to put in place a reasonable supervisory system or fails to actually implement that system and meet supervisory requirements.

IRS Brings Charges Against Barred Broker William Bucci

August 23, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

Back in Decmeber 2013, the law offices of Gana Weinstein LLP reported that “Former Ryan Beck and Oppenheimer Financial Advisor William Bucci Barred From the Financial Industry” where we reported that The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) barred Bucci for allegedly accepting 19 personal loans totaling $635,000 from nine customers in violation of FINRA rules. FINRA also alleged that Bucci willfully failed to amend his Form U4 to disclose material facts relating to two judgments that were entered against him. In addition to these claims, several customers filed complaints alleging that Bucci sold illegal promissory notes.

Recently, a combined investigation by the IRS and the FBI led to the filing of a federal complaint in the Eastern District Court of Pennsylvania against Bucci in connection with the foregoing activities. The complaint alleged that Bucci willfully made Individual Income Tax Return, Form 1040, for the calendar years 2007, 2008, 2009, and 2010 that falsely understated his income.

In addition, a second superseding indictment was filed against Bucci on July 22, 2014, by the United States Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania alleging that Bucci was running an investment fraud scheme that deceived investors into turning over more than $3.2 million. According to a press release issued by the office, Bucci told his victims he was starting a wine and high end olive oil import business to import the goods from Italy. The release stated that Bucci was a licensed stockbroker and a non-lawyer elector on the Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline who never had an olive oil and wine business. The release also alleged that Bucci also solicited individuals to loan money for the purchase of real estate. According to the indictment, Bucci used the funds to supplement his income and to support his lifestyle as well as to make payments to earlier victims.

Broker Robert Livingstone Barred Over Alleged Sales of Newland Strategies to Customers

August 8, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) sanctioned broker Robert Livingstone (Livingstone) concerning allegations that Livingstone failed to respond FINRA’s request for documents concerning claims that Livingstone deposited a customer’s money into a private company called Newland Strategies.

Livingstone first became registered with FINRA in 1992 as a General Securities Representative with Morgan Stanley DW, Inc. Thereafter, in 2001, Livingstone registered with BB&T Investment Services, Inc. (BB&T). Livingstone remained registered with BB&T until the firm filed a Form U5 that terminated his registration with on October 3, 2013. BB&T stated on Livingstone’s BrokerCheck that a “client alleged she thought she invested 200,000 with BBTIS through her BBTIS rep in February 2013. However, it was deposited into a private company called Newland Strategies by her rep and was told she lost $68,000.”

FINRA alleged that in October 2013, BB&T terminated Livingstone’s registration after the firm investigated a customer complaint against Livingstone alleging participation in a private securities transaction. On March 21, 2014, FINRA investigated the customer complaint against Livingstone and requested documents and information from Livingstone. FINRA stated that Livingstone did not produce the requested documents and information after several requests. It was alleged that on April 24, 2014, Livingstone informed FINRA that he would not comply with requests. As a result of Livingstone’s failure to provide documents and information as required by FINRA Rule 8210, FINRA found that Livingstone violated FINRA Rules 8210 and 2010 and imposed a bar from the financial industry.

Former Sterne Agee Broker Dean Mustaphalli Alleged to Have Wrongfully Run $6 Million Hedge Fund

July 15, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

The attorneys at Gana Weinstein LLP are investigating claims that former Sterne Agee Financial Services Inc. (Sterne Agee) broker Dean Mustaphalli (Mustaphalli) solicited millions of dollars from investors running to run a $6 million hedge fund on the side without formerly disclosing the activity to his brokerage firm. As reported by InvestmentNews, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) charged Mustaphalli for founding and receiving commissions from a hedge fund he created called Mustaphalli Capital Partners in or about 2011 without informing his. Mustaphalli sold the investment through his registered investment advisory firm, Mustaphalli Advisory Group.

According to allegations made, Mustaphalli solicited money for the fund from at least 25 investors over six months during 2011. The fund invested in publicly traded equity and debt securities has since declined by approximately 90% according to investors. At least some of Mustaphalli’s clients were direct customers of Sterne Agee as well. According to FINRA, Mustaphalli was not cooperating with the agencies requests to provide account statements for the hedge fund. Typically in these cases if a broker does not cooperate with FINRA’s department of enforcement and the agency proves he withheld information the broker would be barred from the securities industry among other remedies that could be imposed.

Mustaphalli disclosed the existence of the Mustaphalli Advisory to Sterne Agee but did not disclose that he was managing the hedge fund through the firm according to FINRA. However, under the FINRA rules, brokers must fully disclose hedge funds for approval to their member firm and be supervised by the firm under Rule 3040.

Broker David Diehl Sanctioned by FINRA Over the Unauthorized Sale of Promissory Notes

July 9, 2014 | by Staff Attorney

Our law office is investigating potential customer complaints against David Diehl in the wake of the findings and sanctions by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) concerning allegations that Diehl engaged in private securities transactions, often referred to as “selling away”, and an outside business activity without disclosing these activities to his firm, First Liberties Financial. According to FINRA, Diehl was able to raise approximately $480,000 from seven investors for a business which owned and operated three hamburger restaurants in the St. Louis, Missouri area. FINRA found that most of the investors were his brokerage firm client. By virtue of this conduct, FINRA determined that Diehl violated NASD Rules 3030 and 3040 concerning outside business activities.

Diehl has been registered with seven firms since 2004. From July 2010, through March 2012, Diehl was registered with First Liberties Financial (First Liberties). Thereafter, Diehl joined Sunbelt Securities Inc. but left that firm on shortly in April 2012. Diehl was also registered with investment advisors and established an RIA firm, Diehl Wealth Management Group, LLC, in October 2010, and terminated registration in August 2011. Diehl has had three regulatory findings against him including AWC (2012031952301) issued in December 2012 where Diehl was suspended in all capacities for four months and fined $7,500 for indirectly borrowing money from a customer without his firm’s approval and for failing to timely amend his Form U4 to disclose a tax lien totaling $292,965. A broker’s inability to manage his own finances is a relevant disclosure for investors and brokerage firm’s to apply heightened scrutiny the broker’s actions.

Here, FINRA found that Diehl was approached by a client who was a well-known sports figure who wanted to open local burger restaurants under the client’s name. FINRA found that during the latter half of 2010, Diehl participated in establishing the business, and the first of three restaurants opened in April 2011. The restaurants were managed by another individual brought into the business by Diehl. According to FINRA, the restaurant founders set up a corporate entity to own and operate the restaurants and two of Diehl’s close relatives were designated as corporate secretary and director. The address provided for the corporation was Diehl’s home address and the registration of a fictitious name for the restaurants identified Diehl’s office location as the address for the corporation.